Within weeks of Ward’s execution, Hawes & Co. published a 32-page pamphlet, titled The Triple Murderer: The Life and Confessions of Return J.M. Ward. We reprint here the confession he gave concerning his involvement in the murder of the traveling tin peddler, Mr. Lovejoy.
These are his words.
“While Thomas Griffith and I were keeping the Tavern at Richland, an event took place which is very vivid in my recollection, but which I wish I could forget. Griffith was away for the night, and not expected home for several days. Towards evening a peddler, I think his name was Lovejoy, arrived on foot with two large tin trunks full of goods, and said he wanted his supper and breakfast, and a bed for the night, if I would take the amount out in trade. I looked over his goods, and finding that he had such articles as I could use in the family, I made a bargain with him, had his boxes taken care of, and gave him his supper. After supper he walked out for a while, and when he returned, took a seat in the bar-room with me, and we talked for a couple of hours. He complained of being very tired and feeling very much in need of sleep, and said that he had been traveling all day. When he got ready to retire I went with him to his room which was on the second floor, in the corner of the house. At this time no idea of doing him injury had crossed my mind, and after leaving him I went to bed, wholly innocent of any intentions of disturbing his rest or doing violence to his property.
After having slept a couple of hourse, I awoke about midnight, and the thought struck me that perhaps the peddler might have money with him, and that there was a good opportunity to get possession of it. I knew that there was no lock on the door, and, somehow or other, it appeared to me that I must, at any rate, go and see if he had thought to stick his knife over the latch, so as to keep me out. Accordingly I sprang from the bed, and on going to his door found that it was not fastened, and that I could open it without noise. So I opened it and went up softly to the side of the bed and, as I expected, found him sound asleep. The room was almost as light as day, as the moon was shining, and the windows had no curtains. I knew that he was very tired, and calculated that a slight noise would not disturb him.
Everything was so favorable, that the temptaion seemed irresistable, and, leaving the door open, I went down into the bar-room and got an old axe that I knew was kept there, and returned upstairs, with the axe in my hand, to the peddler’s room. I found him still sound asleep and lying in a favorable posistion, so I took hold of the axe with both hands and dealt him a tremendous blow on the top of his head. I struck him only once. He scarcely struggled, and in a few minutes was dead. The blow being on the head, caused but little flow of blood, which was mostly at the nose and mouth, and by a little care on my part the bed was scarcely stained. He made no noise whatever, and all that I had to do was to dispose of the body. This I had not sufficiently considered beforehand, and it presented considerable difficulties, but they were soon surmounted. I went downstairs and got a dry goods box, and, as the body could not be stowed in it whole, I unjointed the legs at the thighs and knees, and after wrapping the various parts that were bloody in sheets and blankets, so as to prevent the blood from oozing out, I packed it all safely in the box, put on the cover, and took the box to my bedroom, where it remained that night, through the following day and the next night. Having disposed of the body, I commenced a search for the money, but found only about fifty dollars. I took out such good from the trunks as would not be likely to expose me, and left the rest in and put them also under my bed, covering them up with an old quilt, and left the bedroom, where the peddler had slept, very little deranged in consequence of the dreadful scene which had just taken place.
The next day I arose as usual and took breakfast with the family. Some inquiries were made after the peddler at the table, and I said that he was up and off by daylight, not choosing to wait for his breakfast, because he had a long way to travel. During the day I made up my mind how I would dispose of the body. I gave out that I was in need of some money, and that I would go to my father’s at Milan, and see if I could not get it of him, and that I believed I would take the wagon and start early on the following morning. So, before day break, I got up and harnessed the horse. No one was stirring about the house, and I had ample time and opportunity to load the box and other things into the wagon without being observed. I traveled through the whole day, directing my course towards the residence of my father, and in the night, about 10 o’clock, reached the neighborhood of the Huron River. When within about half a mile of the river I turned off, into a lot, and went through the lot to the river, so as to be sure of not being seen while unloading. I had previously filled the box with various irons in order to secure its sinking, and finally tumbled it into the river about a mile and a half above Abbott’s Bridge. It sunk to the bottom, and, getting into the wagon again, I returned homeward as rapidly as I could. I never heard that the box was found.
I should have mentioned that, on the night in which killed the peddler, there were but few persons about my house, and no one in that part where he slept. The whole proceeding was conducted very quietly, and there was no noise sufficient to awaken those that slept in the house, even if they had been much nearer to his room. The blow sunk into his head with no reverberation of sound, and as I had taken the precaution to shut the door, it could scarcely have been heard in the next room. Indeed, I was myself surprised that a life could be taken with so little disturbance.”
PREVIOUS >>> The Murder of the Tin Peddler
NEXT >>> A New Life in Shelby
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

