The Murder of the Tin Peddler

By the early 1850s, the settlement of Richland, known to residents as Planktown, had begun to decline. A major reason was transportation. In 1850, the Cleveland & Columbus Railroad was built through Cass Township, but rather than passing through the village, the line ran about a mile to the west. A new settlement soon began to grow where the tracks crossed the main road, and it would become known as Shiloh. Commerce and travel naturally shifted toward the rail crossing, and Planktown gradually lost the importance it had once held as a promising frontier village. An active roadside settlement was slowly cut off from the newer economic routes that were shaping Ohio.

At roughly the same time, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward was still operating the Eagle House. Despite the murder of Noah Hall and the suspicion that lingered in the community, he stayed in the village and carried on his business. Outwardly, life may have looked stable. Inside his household, circumstances had changed dramatically. His wife, Sarah, was gone from daily life, committed to the State Lunatic Asylum in Columbus after coming to believe her husband was responsible for Hall’s death. Some accounts say she was still living at the institution when Ward committed his final crime in 1857.

Her absence affected more than just the household. Sarah appears to have played an important part in managing the daily operations of the Eagle House, and without her Ward reportedly struggled to keep the tavern running efficiently. Much of the money he had taken from Noah Hall had already been spent. Within about a year of Hall’s murder, Ward made another major change. He stepped away from direct management of the tavern, rented the Eagle House to a man named E. Hackett, and held an auction to dispose of much of the furniture and household goods connected with the business. Hackett bought a large portion of the furnishings and effectively took over operations. Ward did not leave right away. For a time he stayed on at the Eagle House, occupying a room and paying rent to Hackett.

The arrangement did not last. Hackett soon tired of managing the boarding house and the business changed hands again. Ward went into partnership with a man named Thomas Griffith and, together, they rented the furniture from Hackett and took over management of the Eagle House. The partnership was brief. According to Ward’s later account, Griffith was a man of intemperate habits and an unsatisfactory partner. Whether that was true, or reflected resentment or Ward’s habit of framing events his own way, is difficult to know. What is clear is that the arrangement did not hold.

It was during this period, while Ward and Griffith were running the Eagle House together, that another traveler arrived in Planktown. In 1852, a tin peddler, known to the historical record only as Mr. Lovejoy, stopped at the tavern for supper and a bed for the night. Traveling peddlers were common in rural communities of the era. They carried practical household goods from settlement to settlement, selling to families who otherwise had limited access to manufactured supplies, and tin peddlers typically carried cups, pans, utensils, and small domestic items packed in crates. Lovejoy arrived with two crates of merchandise. After supper he agreed to stay the night and arranged to settle his bill partly by trading some of his goods to the tavern.

As with Hall, the only account of Lovejoy’s death comes from Ward’s confession, and no remains have ever been found.

At first, the evening appears to have been ordinary. According to Ward’s later confession, the two men spent several pleasant hours talking in the barroom. Eventually, Lovejoy complained of fatigue and said he badly needed sleep. Ward showed him to a room in the corner of the second floor, then retired to his own chamber. By his later account, Ward had no immediate intention of harming the traveler.

Then something changed. Around midnight, Ward confessed, he woke with a thought that began to trouble him. The peddler might be carrying money. The idea grew. Knowing that the door to Lovejoy’s room had no lock, Ward rose quietly and went upstairs. Moonlight coming through the window was bright enough for him to see that Lovejoy was asleep. Ward went back downstairs, took an old axe from the barroom, and climbed the stairs to the room again. According to his confession, Ward gripped the axe with both hands and struck the sleeping peddler with a single powerful blow to the top of the head. The attack was swift. Lovejoy reportedly offered little resistance and died quickly.

Ward then searched the body and was soon disappointed. According to his own account, he found only about fifty dollars, a modest sum and far less than he had imagined would be in the tin peddler’s possession.

The killing left another problem. What to do with the body. Ward later admitted he had not fully thought about how to dispose of it. Acting quickly, he brought a dry goods box up from below. To make the corpse fit inside, he dismembered it. According to his confession, he severed the legs at the thighs and knees, wrapped the remains in sheets and blankets to contain the blood, packed the body into the box, and fastened the lid. He then moved the box into his own bedroom.

The next morning Ward behaved normally. When the peddler did not appear for breakfast, others asked about him, and Ward reportedly said the traveler had risen early and left before breakfast because he had a long journey ahead. No one appeared to have questioned the explanation. Lovejoy had arrived alone, and there were apparently no local relatives or known acquaintances to ask after him. The matter faded, at least for a time.

Later that morning, a local girl Ward had employed as a housekeeper arrived to begin her daily task of cleaning and preparing the rooms for boarders. When she heard the tin peddler had already left, she made preparations to get his room ready for the next prospective occupant. Ward stopped her, stating he had already taken care of everything. Still, she made a mental note to check the room anyway while on her normal rounds through the building. A short time later, the girl came downstairs, her face ashen and scared, and left the Eagle House without saying a word. Ward watched her leave and immediately suspected she may have discovered evidence of his crime.

After crating up the peddler’s body, Ward had made sure to clean up any telltale signs of the murder. The floorboards were wiped clean and bed linens were changed. But, in the dark of night, it was possible he missed something.

Later throughout the day, Ward worked through the problem of how to dispose of the peddler’s body for good. He knew a place where he could dump it where he was sure it would never be found. Here and there, through the course of normal conversation with guests and regulars to the tavern, he made sure to mention he would need to travel in the morning to meet with family.

Before sunrise the next day, Ward loaded the box onto a wagon. Under the pretense of visiting his father in Milan, roughly sixty miles away, he left Planktown with a single horse pulling the wagon. According to accounts derived from his confession, the trip took most of the day, and around ten that night he reached the Huron River near where his father lived. About a mile and a half beyond Abbott’s Bridge, Ward drove toward the riverbank. He had weighted the box with iron and with whatever remaining merchandise from the peddler he did not want to keep, so that it would sink. In the dark, he pushed the crate from the wagon into the river and it disappeared beneath the water. As far as the historical record shows, it was never recovered and no remains believed to be the peddler’s have ever been found.

Ward returned to Planktown and attempted to resume life as before. But the disappearance of Mr. Lovejoy did not pass unnoticed. It is speculated the housegirl whom Ward employed, and had never returned since that fateful morning, had told others of whatever it was she had seen in the peddler’s room because, soon after, rumors began to spread. Some began to suspect that the peddler had met with foul play at the Eagle House.

Historians disagree about how Sarah’s mental collapse fits into this sequence of events. Some argued that Hall’s murder drove her insane. This is the timeline I feel is correct, as well. Others, though, believed the peddler’s disappearance is what finally pushed her over the edge. A. A. Graham, in History of Richland County, suggested that Sarah became insane after the peddler’s disappearance because she suspected her husband of the crime. Another historian, A. J. Baughman, also tied her institutionalization to this event, though he wrongly claimed she died there as well.

As suspicion of Ward deepened, the unexplained disappearance of the traveler revived the earlier doubts about Noah Hall’s death. Many residents came to believe the peddler had been murdered, and many believed Ward was responsible. The atmosphere in the village gradually turned hostile. Ward eventually abandoned the Eagle House altogether, rented it to others, and left Planktown to begin again elsewhere.

By then the village itself was also fading. The railroad town of Shiloh had begun to draw commerce, traffic, and people away from Planktown, and many of its old buildings were removed, abandoned, or torn down. Even the Eagle House did not survive. The tavern where the peddler spent his last night on Earth was eventually destroyed by a windstorm, and one of the most infamous places in Ward’s life vanished from the landscape.

 PREVIOUS >>> Suspicion in the Household

NEXT >>> Ward’s Confession: The Tin Peddler, Mr. Lovejoy

 

Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman

All Rights Reserved

No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.

All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.