In the months after the death of Noah Hall, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward went on running the Eagle House much as he had before. Outwardly little seemed to have changed. He lived among the same neighbors and ran the same business, and travelers still came and went. To those outside his household, Ward appeared to have weathered the suspicion that followed Hall’s murder. Legally, nothing tied him to the crime. Rumors had circulated after the failed prosecution of Daniel Myers and Thomas McGarvy, but authorities had no evidence directly linking Ward to Hall’s death, and without proof the murder remained unresolved in the eyes of the law. Ward continued his life in Planktown.
Inside his home, though, the aftermath appears to have been very different. According to later accounts, his wife, Sarah, strongly suspected that he had been involved in Hall’s killing, and some sources suggest she believed it almost from the beginning. When they were alone, she reportedly confronted him repeatedly and pressed him for an admission of guilt. Whether these were quiet accusations, emotional scenes, or repeated questioning over time is impossible to know, and the record offers only fragments. What is more consistent is that Sarah did not accept his denials. Ward insisted on his innocence and maintained that Hall had been murdered by Myers and McGarvy, the two men who had been arrested and tried before the case collapsed. Sarah remained unconvinced.
One historical description portrays Sarah as an industrious and amiable woman, which suggests she had once been seen as steady, practical, and well regarded. The same accounts describe her suspicions as gradually taking hold of her thoughts. The belief that she was living beside a murderer reportedly weighed heavily on her and, over time, her fear of Ward appears to have deepened. According to later writers, her health declined, her spirits weakened, and her mental condition deteriorated. One account describes her as having become “entirely deranged.”
The record offers very little direct information about Sarah herself. We know almost nothing about her temperament, her emotional life, or what her daily existence in the household was like. Her story survives mostly through later historians, legal records, and the accounts of others, so the causes of her decline are hard to determine.
Money may have been one factor. According to his confession, Ward took nearly eight hundred dollars from Hall after the murder. If Sarah noticed an unexplained change in the household finances, or wondered where the money had come from, it may have deepened her suspicions. That is plausible, but unconfirmed. The atmosphere in Planktown may have been another. Even though Ward had not been charged, the village had not forgotten Hall’s death. Rumors lingered after the trial of Myers and McGarvy and some residents reportedly suspected Ward despite the lack of evidence. Living in a small frontier community where whispered accusations followed her husband may have caused lasting strain. Fear may also have played a part. Contemporary descriptions repeatedly portray Ward as capable of anger, intimidation, and sudden violence, and if Sarah believed he had killed Hall, and had already seen or feared his temper, living beside him may have become deeply unsettling.
The record does not tell us exactly what Sarah believed or what she experienced. We can only speculate. She may have already been struggling with mental illness, prior to and unrelated to Hall’s murder. Stress, suspicion, isolation, fear, or domestic strain may equally have contributed to a genuine psychological collapse, or it could have been some combination of these.
Ward offered his own explanation. According to his account, Sarah had suspected his guilt from the beginning and became consumed by fear that his crime would be exposed. In his telling, her decline came from dwelling on that belief and living in dread of what would happen if the truth came out. How reliable that explanation is remains uncertain. It came from Ward himself, and his confessions and recollections must always be approached with caution.
Historians have also disagreed about the timing of Sarah’s decline. Some accounts say Sarah’s collapse began in the months after Hall’s murder. Others, particularly writers closer to the events, believed her condition worsened later, perhaps after another killing that figures later in this account. The chronology may be disputed and imperfect, but the outcome appears clear. Within roughly a year of Hall’s death, Sarah Ward was committed to the State Lunatic Asylum in Columbus, Ohio.
At the time, the legal rights of women were sharply limited. Husbands and male relatives held enormous authority over whether a woman was placed in an institution, and commitments could be made with little medical scrutiny by modern standards, on the strength of family testimony, local judgment, and community authority. This has led to speculation. Some observers have wondered whether Ward arranged her commitment for reasons beyond concern for her well-being. If Sarah suspected him, or knew something, or if her accusations had become dangerous, confinement would have removed the threat. These interpretations remain speculative, and no direct evidence shows that Ward committed her to the asylum for such reasons.
What can be established is that Sarah remained in the institution for several years. Later accounts suggest her condition improved to some degree. Eventually, she returned to Richland County, where she reportedly found a home with one of her brothers. Her recovery, though, appears to have been incomplete. Some accounts claim she continued to have periodic episodes of mental instability, even though she had regained much of her mental functioning. After life with Ward, she was never the same again.
The marriage between Return Ward and Sarah Lamson Ward ended without divorce or death. It ended through separation, confinement, and distance. Ward stayed in Planktown, running his tavern, while Sarah’s world narrowed to the walls of an asylum and then to the home of relatives.
PREVIOUS >>> Ward’s Confession: Noah Hall
NEXT >>> The Murder of the Tin Peddler
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

