After the tin peddler, Lovejoy, disappeared and suspicion started closing in around him, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward abandoned the Eagle House and left Planktown for good.
His next stop was just up the road, past Shiloh, in the small village of Plymouth, where he went back to tailoring, the trade that had occupied much of his earlier life. For a few months he lived quietly there, supporting himself by sewing and mending garments. According to later accounts, he found the work both pleasant and profitable, and the routine may have given him some stability after the turbulence of his years in Planktown. His stay was brief. After several months he moved to Shelby, also in Richland County, where he again took up his trade and soon established himself in the small community.
Within a few weeks of arriving in Shelby, Ward met a young woman named Susan Reese. Contemporary descriptions portray her as amiable and gentle. The relationship developed quickly, and Ward soon proposed marriage. Susan accepted.
There was a serious complication. As far as we can determine, Ward had never divorced his first wife, Sarah, who was still alive and confined to the State Lunatic Asylum in Columbus. In law, and by the moral expectations of the time, he remained bound to her, which made a second marriage bigamous. Ward went ahead regardless and, in 1853, he and Susan Reese were married in Shelby.
For a time the new household appears to have been stable. Ward continued his tailoring business and, according to some accounts, also ran a profitable boarding house in Shelby, much as he had at the Eagle House. The couple stayed in the area for nearly a year. During that time Susan gave birth to a daughter, who lived only about two months. The infant was buried on the Reese family farm in Shelby County. Infant mortality was high in the mid-nineteenth century, and medical knowledge was limited, so the death was not viewed as unusual or suspicious.
In the fall of 1854, Ward and Susan moved north to Sylvania, in Lucas County. They rented a small wooden building that served as both home and tailor shop, and once again Ward tried to establish himself through his trade. They stayed about a year. During that time Susan became ill. As her condition worsened, Ward took her back to Shelby County to stay with her father, and she lingered there for several months before dying, in early 1856, most likely in January or February.
The official cause of death was recorded as bilious typhoid fever, a diagnosis commonly given in the nineteenth century for severe intestinal illness with fever. At the time, there appears to have been no suspicion of foul play. Ward later said he had cared deeply for Susan and, according to his own account, he visited her often during her illness at her father’s home. After her death he erected gravestones on the Reese farm for his wife and their infant daughter, who were buried together. Ward consistently denied any suggestion that he caused her death. He insisted she had died naturally and said the physician who attended her would confirm it.
After Ward’s arrest and conviction for other crimes, however, doubts arose. Some later observers questioned whether Susan’s death had really been natural after all, and their suspicions drew on hindsight. By then Ward had confessed to multiple killings, and was known to be knowledgeable about various poisons, and people began looking backward through his life for any clues he had killed before.
A pamphlet published by Cornell University near the turn of the twentieth century contains a curious statement attributed to Ward. Reflecting on Susan, he reportedly acknowledged that she had exerted a positive influence on him and that he retained a “faint glimmer of affection” for her memory. At the same time, he admitted that he had treated her unkindly during her pregnancy and suggested that this might have contributed to her death. Whether that statement reflects remorse, exaggeration, or a misunderstood remark repeated later is hard to say. The record contains no clear evidence that Susan Reese Ward was murdered. Her death remains officially attributed to illness and no formal investigation appears to have been conducted.
This period of his life does raise questions that historians have occasionally considered. The Planktown murders had brought Ward money, first the nearly eight hundred dollars taken from Noah Hall and then the smaller sum taken from Lovejoy. Yet it did not give him lasting security. Within a short time much of it had been spent and Ward was again moving from town to town in search of work. Whether greed alone drove his earlier crimes is hard to determine. Some historians have believed money played the central role, while others have noted that his behavior often seemed impulsive and reckless rather than consistently calculating. The available evidence does not allow a final answer. All we can do is speculate as to his motivations.
By the mid-1850s, Ward had left a trail of suspicion and unexplained deaths across several Ohio communities. Yet despite the rumors that followed him, he kept forming new associations and settling in new places. With Susan’s death, he was alone again.
PREVIOUS >>> Ward’s Confession: The Tin Peddler, Mr. Lovejoy
NEXT >>> His Third Wife, Olive
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

