In the early years of his marriage to Sarah Lamson, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward continued to live and work in Mansfield, in Richland County. The town had grown steadily as settlers spread throughout northern Ohio, and like most frontier communities it depended on tradesmen. Tailors, blacksmiths, carpenters, merchants, and laborers who served the surrounding farms and businesses.
Ward was still working as a tailor when another violent episode deepened the reputation that had begun to form around him. According to one contemporary source, he had recently joined a shop where several younger workers were employed. Among tradesmen, practical jokes and teasing were sometimes treated as an initiation for newcomers. They could be harmless, or they could turn into a sustained effort to provoke or embarrass the new man. At some point, one of those jokes appears to have crossed a line and Ward reacted violently. Enraged, he seized a stone reportedly kept in the shop for cracking nuts and hurled it at one of the men involved, a young man named Myers. The stone struck Myers in the face and knocked him unconscious. For a time, witnesses reportedly feared the blow had killed him.
Myers recovered, but the assault had legal consequences. Ward was arrested and jailed, and unable to make bail, he remained in jail for several weeks awaiting trial. When the case came before the court, he was convicted of assault and battery. The sentence was brief. Ward was to spend several days in the county jail, subsisting only on a diet of bread and water. The incident showed again how quickly a minor conflict could turn serious when Ward lost his temper. A workplace prank had ended in serious injury, imprisonment, and a criminal conviction, and it reinforced a pattern that was becoming hard to ignore. An ordinary situation, sudden anger, violence, and then legal trouble. The pattern of Ward’s life was almost predictable.
Ward’s circumstances soon shifted again. About a year after his marriage to Sarah, his business in Mansfield appears to have faltered. The nature of the failure is not clearly documented, but whatever he had been pursuing no longer offered stability. Facing financial difficulty, Ward and his wife left Mansfield around 1844 and moved to Cass Township, also in Richland County.
The move did not bring lasting calm, however. Soon after arriving, Ward became involved in yet another dispute that put him before the local authorities. This time it was over a business arrangement. Ward had made a coat for a man named Morse and payment was supposed to be arranged through a trade involving a local merchant named Boles. The arrangement broke down. What caused the disagreement is unclear, but Ward reportedly took offense at something in Boles’s conduct and refused to complete the transaction on the original terms. Morse eventually paid for the coat himself, which settled the money question, but the larger conflict continued. During the dispute, Ward reportedly suggested that if Morse would “thrash” Boles, he could have the coat without payment. The remark did not stay private. Word reached Boles, who was offended and alarmed, and he took legal action. Ward was arrested and placed under a peace bond, a legal measure meant to prevent further violence between the two men.
For a short time the matter seemed to be over. Then Boles’s ash house, a small outbuilding used to store ashes from stoves and fireplaces, caught fire and was destroyed. The cause was never clearly established, but suspicion quickly turned to Ward. An arson charge was brought and he was arrested again. The magistrate set bail at five hundred dollars, a considerable sum for the period. When the case came before a jury, the prosecution failed to produce enough evidence for a conviction, and Ward was acquitted.
Legally, the case ended there, but acquittal did not erase suspicion. In small frontier communities, a verdict often mattered less than reputation and rumor could outlast evidence. Ward’s earlier disputes likely did little to quiet the doubts and even those who thought the evidence insufficient may still have wondered whether he had played some part. This lingering suspicion may have made life in Cass Township increasingly difficult for Ward and Sarah. Although the law had cleared him, the cloud around his name appears to have remained.
After living in the area for two or three years, the couple left again, this time moving north to New Haven in neighboring Huron County. There Ward went back to work and, according to later accounts, appears to have done business successfully for a time. The move gave him something he sought repeatedly throughout his life, a fresh start. In a new town, old accusations and disputes may have counted for less. Relocating this way was not unusual on the frontier, where tradesmen often left a settlement when suspicion, failed business, or conflict made life there difficult, and moved to places where opportunity remained and their past was less familiar.
For Ward, though, the pattern of his life was becoming clear. Conflict, accusation, departure, and another town. By this stage of his life, his movement no longer seems to have been driven only by work or opportunity. Looking back on his life, one might think it was increasingly motivated by his desire to outrun trouble.
PREVIOUS >>> His First Wife
NEXT >>> The Eagle House
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

