His First Wife

By the early 1840s, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward had begun to leave a stronger impression on the communities where he lived. His years of movement across northern Ohio had carried him from town to town, but wherever he stayed, even briefly, people remembered him. Part of that memory appears to have been tied to his physical presence.

Later descriptions of Ward are striking. He was remembered as a large, heavyset man with broad shoulders, a thick neck, and a squat but powerful frame. His head was said to be nearly bald except for a narrow ring of dark, wiry hair around the sides, and his face was clean-shaven apart from a prominent goatee. His appearance alone, by these accounts, made an impression before he even spoke.

One of the more vivid descriptions comes from the historian A. A. Graham in History of Richland County. Graham described Ward as resembling “the living personification of the ogres of the fairy tales,” a large and imposing man with a broad forehead, a thick neck, and what he called a “sinister, forbidding countenance.”

Other observers described him in similar terms. His language was often said to be coarse and, when angered, he could become verbally abusive. His temper was known to rise quickly and the earlier violent incidents in his life had already begun to circulate in local memory. Together these recollections created the image of a man who could seem intimidating before any conflict began.

Yet Ward was not without personal appeal. Despite the reputation that followed him in some circles, he seems to have had enough charm to attract the interest of women. During his years in Milan, one account says he became involved with a young woman whose affection he had won. After professing love and promising marriage, Ward reportedly seduced her. According to later accounts, he then abandoned the engagement and left the area. The woman’s identity was not preserved, and many of the details are cloudy. Even so, the episode hints at an ability to attract and persuade that would appear again later in Ward’s life, despite a reputation that might otherwise have driven people away.

At some point after leaving Milan, Ward traveled south into Richland County and spent time in the village of Bellville, where he stayed for a while with his brother-in-law, Isaac Collins. During this period he appears to have drifted from the discipline of his trade. Later descriptions say that he “gave himself up for a time to young company” and largely abandoned tailoring. What that phrase meant is not explained. It may mean socializing, drinking, or simply idleness and neglect of regular work. The record does not say, but it does suggest a period in which work and routine counted for less.

Eventually Ward moved again, this time to Mansfield, also in Richland County, where he entered a business partnership with a man named James B. Cole. At first the arrangement looked financially promising. Ward was a trained tailor who could earn a respectable wage and, for a time, the partnership seems to have worked. But, as in his earlier employments, the stability did not last. Cole grew suspicious of Ward. The reason for that suspicion is not clear, but it was serious enough that Cole refused to let Ward continue to control the business accounts or collect the bills owed to the firm. The disagreement escalated. In response, Ward reportedly gathered the firm’s account books, which were said to record charges totaling between eight hundred and one thousand dollars, and burned them. The destruction of the records not only ended the partnership but erased any documentation of debts owed to the business. Whatever trust had existed between the two men was gone, and there was little chance of reconciliation.

His time in Mansfield would be important for another reason. While living there, Ward met a young woman named Sarah Lamson. (Some accounts call her Sarah Terman, but most sources identify her as Sarah Lamson.) Surviving accounts describe her as coming from a respectable family. Her father was a prominent farmer and a man of standing in the community, and from the start he strongly opposed Ward as a husband for his daughter. Why he objected is not known, but Ward’s reputation may have played a part. By this stage in his life, Ward had already been involved in disputes, violent outbursts, and difficult business relationships in several towns, and his temper was known to many who met him. Whether Sarah’s father knew the full extent of those incidents is unclear. What does seem certain is that he considered Ward an unsuitable match.

The couple went ahead with their romance anyway. In 1843, Return Ward and Sarah Lamson were married, reportedly after eloping against her father’s wishes. The marriage was not without its consequences. When her father learned that they had married, despite his objections, he removed Sarah from his will and effectively disinherited her. According to surviving accounts, she was now only entitled to receive a small provision of two hundred dollars, payable ten years after his death. Ward later tried to challenge the will in court, hoping to secure what he believed was his wife’s rightful share of the estate. The effort failed. The courts ruled against him and the will stood.

Whether Ward entered the marriage expecting financial gain is suspected, but uncertain. Some historians have suggested he saw the union as a path to property, inheritance, or social standing through the Lamson family, in which case Sarah’s disinheritance would have sharply altered his expectations. That remains speculation. It is equally possible that the marriage grew from real affection between two young people willing to proceed despite family opposition. The record offers little of Sarah Lamson’s own perspective. What we know of her comes largely through the decisions of the men around her.

By 1843, then, Ward had entered his first marriage. He was no longer simply a wandering tradesman moving between shops and temporary arrangements. He had found a household of his own. But the patterns and traits already visible in his life remained. His temper, his restlessness, his instability in business and personal relationships, and his repeated moves from place to place. These were all patterns and behaviors which would mark his life.

 PREVIOUS >>> Troubles Begin

NEXT >>> Trouble Follows

 

Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman

All Rights Reserved

No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.

All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.