Childhood Lost

The Ward family had come to the Firelands as pioneers, clearing farms from out of the forest along the Huron River in the earliest years of settlement. Roads were cut through rough land and small communities formed along the muddy tracks that connected one homestead to the next. Return Jonathan Meigs Ward was born into that world on June 8, 1815.

The details of his earliest years are unsurprisingly sparse. Few documents have managed to survive the centuries and not every family name was able to earn a spot in county histories. What can be said with some degree of confidence is that tragedy came to the Ward household early. Return’s mother, Huldah Ward, died in 1817, when he was two years old, leaving several young children without a mother at a time when frontier life was already hard on families.

What followed is one of the first mysteries of Ward’s life. Most accounts agree that sometime after his mother’s death, the boy was sent away from his father’s home to be raised elsewhere. Beyond that, the record is hard to follow. The sources say little about when it happened, why, or what the household looked like at the time, and later historians have had to piece the story together from scattered and, sometimes, conflicting fragments.

One version appears in Milan Pioneer Stories: The Tragic Story of Return Ward. According to that account, Return was sent away almost immediately after his mother’s death, while his brothers Elam and Collins, and his sisters Sarah and Betsey, remained at home with their father. The account has some inconsistencies. It makes no mention of another sister, Rhoda Ward, who other records show was already married and living in Massachusetts. Whether her absence is an oversight or the result of incomplete information is unclear.

Other versions place the separation later. Many retellings say Return was sent away at about five years old. Historians and folklorists have repeated the detail often enough that it has become part of the standard story, but no surviving documentation confirms it, and it is unclear where this detail first came from.

What appears more consistently across the accounts is that Return spent at least part of his childhood outside his immediate family. He was said to have been “put out” to be raised by others, people who were in effect strangers to him. If so, he grew up without his mother and outside the ordinary circle of family that might otherwise have shaped him. But even this is not entirely certain.

Genealogical research by Doris R. Sheridan raises questions about the traditional version of his early life. Her findings suggest that several of the Ward children may already have been living apart from their father by the time Return was born or shortly afterward. It is possible that all of the siblings, except Collins, had already left the household and married, despite their young ages.

There is other evidence points the opposite way. Census records from 1850 show Elam still living in the Ward household, so at least one sibling stayed with their father well into adulthood. Collins, meanwhile, eventually appears in Monroe County, Michigan, which suggests that he, too, spent time away from the homestead. Taken together, these details make the household’s structure during Return’s childhood difficult to reconstruct. The movements of the Ward children appear to have been more complicated than later storytellers assumed.

The reasons for Return’s removal are even harder to find. No contemporary record explains why Jared Ward chose, or felt compelled, to place his young son with others, and writers have been left to speculate.

Some have suggested economic hardship. Crop failures, illness, and scarcity strained frontier families in newly settled country, and if the Ward farm fell on hard times, Jared may simply have been unable to support all of his children.

Others have offered more personal explanations. One theory holds that Return was illegitimate, the result of an affair his father found difficult to confront after his wife’s death, and that placing the boy with another family seemed easier than raising him at home. No evidence supports this, however, and it remains one of several speculative theories that have grown up around Ward’s early life. A few later commentators, looking back through the lens of his violent adulthood, even wondered whether the boy himself had some connection to his mother’s death. That idea has no documented basis, either. It says more about the habit of searching a childhood for early signs of later violence than it does about the evidence.

Other explanations are rooted in the realities of frontier life and offer a much more logical reason for Return Ward’s departure from the family farm. Jared may have believed his son would do better learning a trade than staying on the farm. Farming demanded strength and skill, and if Return showed little aptitude or interest, his father may have decided his future lay elsewhere. Frontier families often placed children with neighbors, relatives, or tradesmen to learn a craft, so the arrangement may have been an apprenticeship rather than an abandonment. Whether that was the case here is unknown, but it seems to be the most reasonable explanation.

A change in the household may also have played a part. Jared eventually remarried, to a woman named Asenath Russell, and some historians have wondered whether the marriage contributed to Return’s displacement. Asenath reportedly had two sons from an earlier relationship, Olcott and Charles, eleven and nine years old, respectively. A stepmother unwilling to take on her husband’s children from his first marriage may have influenced the decision, or a conflict among the children may have made the household unworkable. Frontier homes were small and resources were often limited. No record confirms any of this, of course. These are possibilities, not facts.

In later years, some observers wondered whether the early separation shaped Ward’s character. Some writers have gone further, linking his hostility toward children, particularly the children his third wife, Olive, brought into his household, to his own upbringing. Whether such a connection exists cannot be known for certain.

What can be said is limited to only what we know and that is Ward’s early life appears to have been marked by loss and separation. His mother died before he could even remember her and his place in the family is hard to reconstruct. By adulthood, he had begun a life of movement, from one home to another, from one trade to the next, and from one town to another across northern Ohio. Little more survives of those years.

 PREVIOUS >>> Descended From Revolutionaries and Pioneers

NEXT >>> Life on the Water

 

Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman

All Rights Reserved

No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.

All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.