By 1841, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward was twenty-six. After years of moving through towns along the southern shore of Lake Erie and working as a tailor in the growing settlements of the Great Lakes region, he returned once again to Milan, where much of his early life had unfolded. He was no longer a boy shifting between apprenticeships and relatives. He was a grown tradesman, skilled, mobile, and able to earn a living at his craft. This period also contains some of the earliest, clearly recorded signs of the violent temper that would later define how others remembered him.
In Milan, Ward went back to work for a familiar employer, Baxter Ashley, the tailor under whom he had apprenticed several years earlier. Ashley’s shop stood on the west side of the town square. Tailor shops in frontier towns like Milan were often cramped, with several men working side by side at narrow benches under low ceilings and small windows. In cold weather, doors and shutters were usually kept closed to hold the warmth, which made the workrooms close and uncomfortable.
It was in this setting that one of the earliest recorded violent episodes of Ward’s adult life took place. According to later accounts, Ward became involved in a dispute with another journeyman tailor named John Quincy Adams. It began over something that seemed minor. Adams complained that the shop had grown too warm and stuffy, and he opened the doors and windows to let in air. Ward objected. Whether the quarrel was only about comfort, or whether deeper tensions already existed between the two men, the record does not say.
The exchange escalated quickly. Ward reportedly told Adams that if the conditions did not suit him, he could leave. Adams refused. Ward closed the doors and windows, and Adams opened them again. According to one account, Ward warned that if Adams opened the doors once more, he would “knock him to Hell.” Adams opened them anyway.
What followed was sudden. Ward sprang from his workbench and seized a heavy wooden lap board, a tailor’s tool used as a working surface for cutting and stitching. He swung it at Adams’s head with full force. Adams just barely avoided the blow, but the board struck his shoulder, reportedly dislocating the joint and knocking him to the floor. Before he could recover, Ward struck him again. Adams scrambled out of the shop. His shoulder was said to be either broken or badly dislocated, and he later sought medical treatment to have it set.
Adams also went to the law and a warrant was issued for Ward’s arrest. The incident could have grown far more serious, but it appears to have been cut short by family intervention. Ward’s father, Jared Ward, stepped in and pressed for a private settlement rather than a court case. This fact is significant. Despite the stories of separation in Return’s childhood, his father was still involved in his life well into adulthood, and Jared’s willingness to step in appears to have kept the assault from becoming a larger legal matter.
Ward later described the settlement in his own words:
“My father said I would get myself into trouble and had better settle the matter. So I sent for Adams and asked him what he would take to settle it. He said $10. I said I would see him in Hell first. I then put my hand in my pocket and pulled out $5 and laid it down and told him that if he would take that I would settle it. He accordingly took it and I heard no more of the affair.”
With the payment of five dollars, Adams dropped the charges, and the matter was considered closed.
This episode stands out for more than just the assault. Later accounts by people who knew Ward frequently describe him as being prone to sudden anger, a man whose temper could move from irritation to violence in an instant. That pattern is already visible here. A quarrel over ventilation in a tailor shop ended with a man injured on the floor and a legal complaint that took his father’s intervention to resolve.
A more serious assault followed in Mansfield, Ohio, an episode told in full in a future chapter. The two incidents suggest, and reinforce, a pattern. Ward would often answer conflict with sudden physical violence and, in both cases, the triggers were strikingly minor, a disagreement over airflow and a practical joke. The reactions were disproportionate, fast, and dangerous. As he moved from town to town in search of work, the trait appears to have gone with him.
At this stage, Ward was still, outwardly, a working tradesman. A tailor earning a living in the expanding towns of northern Ohio. His trade gave him mobility and the economy still offered work for skilled hands. From the outside, his life may have looked ordinary, but, beneath that routine, something more unstable was beginning to show. His temper was not merely quick. It appears to have been explosive and its consequences would grow far more serious than a broken shoulder in a tailor’s shop.
PREVIOUS >>> The Wandering Tailor
NEXT >>> His First Wife
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

