The marriage between Return Jonathan Meigs Ward and his third wife, Olive Davis Ward, deteriorated quickly after they arrived in Sylvania, Ohio. The disagreements had deepened into open quarrels and, within a few months, the house on Division Street was a place of continual tension. Later testimony from neighbors and acquaintances suggests that the trouble went well beyond ordinary domestic disagreement. Olive increasingly told others she was unhappy in the marriage and feared the temper of the man she had married.
One of the earliest glimpses into the household comes from Jane Kirkby, who visited the Ward home shortly before Christmas of 1856. According to her testimony, Olive was ill at the time. During their conversation, Olive explained that she had taken a medicine made from green coffee. Kirkby testified that Olive told her she “would not have a child by that man to save her soul.” The medicine, Olive said, had been used to produce an abortion several days earlier. Kirkby recalled being asked to wash clothing stained with blood afterward. The blood from the wash water was thrown out with the household slops in a corner of the shed. She remembered that the quantity of blood was not large and that only Olive’s linen and part of the bedding had been washed.
Another witness, Liba Allen, who ran a small store near Ward’s home, described a conversation he had with Ward during the same period. Allen testified, Ward also spoke of the abortion. He said he had given Olive the coffee that caused it and that the aborted fetus had been burned in the stove. Whether these statements were exaggeration, bravado, or an accurate account is difficult to determine from the surviving record. What is clear is that by the closing weeks of 1856 the marriage was already deeply troubled.
Other testimony shows how openly Olive had begun to share her fears. Catherine Hubbard, the wife of Ward’s brother-in-law, told the court that Olive had spoken openly about the marriage. According to Hubbard, Olive said that Ward was “not an agreeable man to live with” and that she did not love him. Asked why she had married him, Olive reportedly answered that Ward had promised her a good home for herself and her children. The promise had not lasted. Within weeks, Ward had refused to keep the children in the house and Olive had been forced to find other places for them to live. Hubbard testified that Olive said this had turned whatever affection she once felt for Ward into resentment.
Olive also spoke of her fear. Hubbard remembered her saying that when she thought about her situation, she sometimes believed she would rather risk her life escaping than go on living with him. She described a plan to leave without confronting him. Olive had a wooden key that could unlock the door and, one day, when Ward was away from the house, she intended to retrieve her belongings and leave before he could stop her.
Other witnesses described a similar atmosphere. Mrs. Haley testified that Ward had once threatened Olive with a dirk, a small dagger, and that Olive told her Ward warned that if she tried to leave him it “would be the death of her.” Haley also said she had heard the couple quarrel many times. Sometimes Olive left the house during these quarrels and took temporary refuge with neighbors before returning. The relationship, though, was not without moments of reconciliation. Haley remembered Olive saying at times that Ward could be good to her, which suggests a marriage that would shift uneasily between conflict and fragile calm. The broader pattern, though, pointed toward collapse.
According to accounts gathered later in the investigation, Ward was widely regarded as a man of violent temper. Olive reportedly told others that he kept a revolver under his pillow and carried poison with him. Whether these were literal descriptions or expressions of her fear is not certain, but they show how anxious she was about remaining in the house.
Eventually, Olive made a decision. Sometime in late 1856, or possibly early January of 1857, she resolved to leave Sylvania and return to Adrian, Michigan, where she had lived before marrying Ward. The exact date is not known. Some accounts place the departure in November, others closer to January. Either way, the sequence of events shows how determined she had become to get away.
Olive quietly gathered her belongings and prepared to leave town, apparently intending to go without confronting her husband. But Ward quickly discovered what she was doing. He hurried from the house to the Sylvania railroad depot to intercept her before the train left. By the time he arrived, Olive was already at the station, arranging to board the train for Adrian.
Several witnesses remembered what happened next. In the confusion of her departure, Ward managed to intercept her trunk before it could be loaded into the baggage car and seized it, refusing to let it go with her. William Warren, who happened to be near the depot, later testified that Ward had taken possession of the trunk and, during the confrontation, snatched the bonnet from Olive’s head. It was remembered afterward as a particularly humiliating moment, since it happened in front of others at the station. Even so, Olive did not change her mind. Without her trunk, and now without her bonnet, she boarded the train and left for Adrian. Ward was left behind at the depot.
He did not accept the separation and soon followed her to Michigan. In Adrian, he found Olive at the boarding house of B. M. Phillips, where she had taken refuge, and tried to persuade her to come back with him. She refused. According to those who later described the encounter, she told him plainly that she did not like him well enough to live with him any longer.
For a time, the two lived apart, Olive in Adrian and Ward in his small house on Division Street in Sylvania. The separation was incomplete, however, as a good quantity of Olive’s belongings remained in the house with Ward. Recovering them would eventually require her to return. If she wanted her belongings, she have to come back to Sylvania, back to the house she had struggled to escape and to the man she feared.
PREVIOUS >>> His Third Wife, Olive
NEXT >>> The Return to Sylvania
Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman
All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.
All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.

