The Return to Sylvania

After Olive left Sylvania for Adrian, Michigan, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward did not give up on persuading her to come back. Their separation had come only a short time after the wedding and, despite the bitterness between them, Ward soon began looking for ways to mend things.

At first he sought help from others. He hired a Sylvania man named William Warren and sent him to Adrian to speak to Olive on his behalf. According to Warren’s later testimony, Ward asked him to say that he wanted her to return and live with him again. If she did, Ward promised to mend his ways. He would treat her more kindly, allow her more freedom to visit neighbors, and stop accusing her of improper conduct.

Warren found Olive in Adrian and, after relaying Ward’s promises, she did not agree at once. He testified that she told him she was afraid to live with Ward and feared that if she went back he might kill her. Only after Warren repeated Ward’s assurances did she reluctantly agree to consider it. But, she set conditions. Ward would have to pay for her train fare and Warren was to see that Ward kept his promises. When Warren returned to Sylvania with her answer, Ward readily agreed, paid him four dollars for his trouble, and sent Olive the money. According to Warren, she agreed to take a Saturday night train that was scheduled to reach Sylvania around 1:55 in the morning.

Warren was not Ward’s only attempt at convincing Olive to reconsider. Before this arrangement, Ward had already gone to Adrian himself to persuade her in person. B. M. Phillips, an Adrian resident who had taken Olive into his home, later described one of those encounters. Phillips recalled that Ward came to his house and tried to convince Olive to return with him. In Ward’s presence, she refused. She said plainly that she would not go back to Sylvania because he had threatened her life and she feared he might carry out the threat. Ward did not deny making the threats but told her she should understand he had not meant them seriously. Olive remained unwilling. In the end, with Warren’s help and Ward’s repeated promises, she left Adrian by train on a Saturday night and returned to Sylvania as arranged.

She arrived near the end of January 1857. Ward met her at the depot and took her back to the small house on Division Street where they had lived together.

For Ward, her return may have looked like a chance to repair the marriage. He had spent weeks trying to bring her back, first through an intermediary and then by going to Adrian himself, and her agreement could easily have seemed as a willingness to try again. For Olive, the purpose of the trip appears to have been very different. Dr. T. G. Cosgrove later testified that Olive told him she was going back to Sylvania only to recover her clothing and other belongings. She explained that she had tried to leave Ward once before and had been stopped at the depot, where he took her trunk and even removed the bonnet from her head, so that she had to travel to Adrian without it. Now she meant to retrieve what she had left behind and then leave again. In the same conversation, Olive spoke to Cosgrove about the abortion she had induced with green coffee. She warned him that the method was dangerous and said that when she used it she had nearly bled to death.

The days after her return were tense. The couple lived under one roof again, but Olive made little effort to hide her plans. She had left Ward once and intended to do so again as soon as she had gathered the rest of her belongings. Neighbors and acquaintances later recalled that she spoke openly about it. Catherine Green testified that she heard Olive say she meant to leave Ward as soon as she safely could. According to Green, Olive explained that she had come back from Adrian only to get her clothing, that she did not feel safe living with him, and that she could not remain with him because she had not been able to keep her children with her in the household. Others recalled her fear. Accounts later gathered during the investigation say she believed Ward might take her life, repeating the claims noted earlier that he kept a revolver under his pillow and sometimes carried poison in his pocket.

William Warren, who had helped bring her back, saw the couple again after she returned. He testified that in one conversation Ward remarked that he had “some friends and a great many enemies.” Ward then took a folded paper from his wallet and said its contents would quiet some of them “if they did not look out.” The implication being there was some kind of poison held within it. Warren could not say what was in the folded paper, or whether anything was, but the remark suggested that Ward felt himself surrounded by hostility and suspicion. Warren also remembered Ward speaking harshly about Olive in the days prior to her leaving him the first time. At one point Ward called the person in Adrian who had recommended Olive to him a “damned old fool” and described Olive as a difficult woman. Despite these remarks, he continued to insist that he wanted her to stay.

For several days the couple remained in the house on Division Street in an uneasy truce, with Olive continuing to collect the clothing and belongings she meant to take with her. On Tuesday, February 3, 1857, she took another step toward securing an end to the marriage. That day she wrote to B. M. Phillips in Adrian, the man who had sheltered her before, and asked him to come and take her away from Sylvania. Her intentions were now unmistakable.

That evening, shortly after dark, Olive stepped out to visit a neighbor, Mrs. Harriet Nathans, who kept a small henhouse behind her home and sold eggs to supplement her income. Olive arrived carrying a wicker basket and asked for a dozen eggs, saying she meant to make custard pies. Mrs. Nathans later testified that the visit took place around six o’clock. During the conversation, Olive again mentioned that she expected to leave Ward soon. After buying the eggs she said good night and walked back toward the house on Division Street. Mrs. Nathans never saw her again.

Later that night, Ward and Olive argued once more. The subject was the same one that had divided them for weeks: Olive’s determination to leave him and go back to Adrian. She made no effort to hide it. The letter she had written that day made it clear that she expected help in leaving Sylvania and she had already begun gathering what she planned to take.

What passed through Ward’s mind in the hours that followed cannot be known. Some have suggested that a man prone to anger, resentment, and wounded pride may have spent the evening brooding over Olive’s declaration and the humiliation of being rejected. That remains speculation. What is clear is that the conflict had reached its final stage. For weeks the marriage had been coming apart. Olive had left once, come back only to retrieve her belongings, and made it unmistakable that she was leaving again.

In the small house on Division Street, the last hours of the marriage between Return Jonathan Meigs Ward and Olive Davis Ward were passing the point of no return. By morning, it would all end in violence.

 PREVIOUS >>> Olive Leaves

NEXT >>> The Murder of Olive Ward

 

Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman

All Rights Reserved

No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.

All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.