The Murder of Noah Hall

By the early 1850s, Return Jonathan Meigs Ward was firmly established as the proprietor of the Eagle House in the small village of Richland, better known as Planktown. The tavern stood at a busy corner of the settlement and was more than a boarding house. It was a gathering place for travelers, laborers, merchants, and local residents, and in a frontier village such an establishment stood near the center of daily life.

Among the men who regularly frequented it was a merchant named Noah Hall.

Hall had arrived in Planktown around 1849 and become a familiar figure in the village. He ran the local general store, an important business for a community of farms and scattered households. Stores like his supplied what families could not easily make for themselves, like cloth, tools, dry goods, household necessities, and trade items. According to the historian A. A. Graham in History of Richland County, Hall was also a regular boarder at Ward’s establishment.

Nearly everything known about how Noah Hall died comes from Ward himself. The trial of Daniel Myers and Thomas McGarvy established that Hall had been killed, but the account of who did it, and how, comes from the confession Ward gave in the spring of 1857, which he later recanted from the scaffold. What follows is his version, and it should be read with that in mind.

Hall was around fifty years old, and later descriptions often note that he lived much like a bachelor. One account refers to “some difference with his wife,” which reportedly kept him from spending much time at home. He often ate his meals at the Eagle House and slept at the back of his store. The store stood on the south side of Sandusky Street, a short distance west of Ward’s tavern. It was described as a simple frame building, somewhat isolated from its neighbors, with its entrance facing the street. In the back, Hall kept a cot where he usually slept.

By early March of 1851, Hall was preparing for an important trip. Country merchants of the time often traveled to the larger eastern cities to buy stock, since large wholesale distribution systems did not yet exist. These trips required weeks of preparation, including collecting debts and gathering payments, and the merchant often carried a substantial sum of money. Hall had reportedly spent several weeks doing exactly that. The exact amount was not widely known, but it appears to have been generally understood that he had collected a considerable amount of cash for the impending trip.

One evening, while dining at the Eagle House, Hall mentioned his plans. During conversation he told Ward that he intended to leave soon for New York to buy merchandise, that he expected to go within a day or two, and that he would be carrying the money he had collected.

According to Ward’s later confession, this was when the idea began to take shape. He claimed that sometime after learning of Hall’s plans, the thought of robbery, and of murder, came to him. Ward decided to kill Noah Hall and take the money he believed the merchant was carrying.

The following evening, while Hall was again at the Eagle House eating dinner, Ward quietly slipped away and went to Hall’s store. There he reportedly unfastened the rear door and left it unsecured so that he could return later without difficulty. Then he waited. Shortly after midnight on the morning of March 18, 1851, Ward armed himself with a heavy iron poker and went back to the store. As he expected, Hall was asleep on his cot at the rear of the building.

In his confession, Ward described what happened:

“Having carefully ascertained his position, I struck the rounded point through his skull on the left side above the ear, and then gave him a violent blow with the heavy end of the poker on the top of his head.”

By his own account, the attack did not end there. Hall struggled. Ward claimed that, in order to silence him, he pressed a pillow tightly over Hall’s mouth and gripped his windpipe with his other hand, holding him down until the struggle stopped. In another part of the confession, Ward reportedly admitted:

“It was a fearful struggle, and I felt sad relief it was over.”

When Hall was dead, Ward searched for the money and eventually found it. According to the account, he took nearly eight hundred dollars, a significant amount of money for the period. Before leaving, he arranged the store to look like a burglary had been committed, hoping it would appear that outside robbers had broken in, killed Hall, and taken the money. His aim, obviously, was to deflect suspicion.

The next morning, Planktown woke to the news that Noah Hall had been found dead inside his store. In a small frontier village word spread quickly, residents gathered, and questions and suspicion followed. As local authorities and townspeople tried to work out who might have done it, Ward did something that later stood out sharply. According to surviving accounts, he actively helped direct suspicion toward two local men, Daniel Myers and Thomas McGarvy. The two were brothers-in-law, described in contemporary accounts as Irish laborers who had developed reputations as troublesome figures in the area.

Based on Ward’s efforts to focus suspicion on the men, authorities arrested them, and a grand jury indicted both for Hall’s murder. At trial, Ward even appeared as one of the principal witnesses for the prosecution and his testimony was part of the effort to establish that Myers and McGarvy had committed the crime. But the proceedings did not go as expected. Inconsistencies reportedly emerged in Ward’s testimony and parts of his account did not fully align with other evidence. Doubts grew about his reliability and the prosecution’s case weakened considerably because of it. The jury eventually found the evidence insufficient to convict and Myers was acquitted. The charges against McGarvy were dismissed soon afterward.

With the case collapsing, attention began to shift to Ward himself. Some residents of Planktown began to suspect him and several things stood out to people who knew him. They knew of his closeness to Hall, his knowledge of Hall’s plans, his role in steering suspicion elsewhere, and his testimony. But suspicion was not proof. Despite growing doubt in the community, no direct evidence could be produced linking Ward to the murder and, without it, authorities could not bring charges. Legally, the killing remained unsolved and Ward remained free.

He continued to run the Eagle House and to live among the neighbors who had known Noah Hall. Over time, the shock of the murder seems to have faded into rumor and unresolved doubt. Many in the community reportedly believed Ward was responsible. But belief was not enough and the law had no way to prove it. Return Jonathan Meigs Ward remained free in Planktown, running his business, while the murder of Noah Hall remained, at least publically, unsolved.

 PREVIOUS >>> The Eagle House

NEXT >>> Ward’s Confession: Noah Hall

 

Ward: The Life and Crimes of Ohio’s First Serial Killer, Copyright (c) 2026 Christopher Tillman

All Rights Reserved

No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the express written consent of the author and publisher.

All graphics in this book are either images of existing documents, enhanced using A.I. for clarity and readability, or artistic renderings and interpretations of events described in the text.